Google+  
 

Communism: Realistic or Utopian dream?

Subscribe to this topic Low Bandwidth Favourite Forums
Search this topic:

Displaying Page 1 of 1. | Go To Page:
Down to Quick Reply

Post ID: 3096522 Posted at: 25-Feb-2012 15:56:05
cheatos_42
Member
Joined: 19 Sep 2006
Posts: 585
Post Likes: 0
+
I'd like to hear people's views from SC on the theory and Ideology of Communism, as I am a member of the Communist Party of Great Britain (Marxist-Leninist).

I don't want hating or flaming, just people's opinions on Marx's theory, and obviously, keep this a philosophical Discussion, not a tense debate.

(This is the 10,000th post in the D&D forums by the way :P)
0
+
Reply Add Quote and ReplyMulti Quote
Post ID: 3096732 Posted at: 26-Feb-2012 10:06:19
the dawn of the gamers
Member
Joined: 22 Nov 2010
Posts: 395
Post Likes: 0
+
Honestly, there are upsides and downsides. Clearly it has failed in the past, but it could be argued that the main reason for its failure in the past was mostly due to the corrupt dictators of the time. Granted, governments now aren't exactly free of corruption, but if we could ever get decent people in leadership, then communism may not fail.

We might be better off returning to a bartering system than anything else.
There are many powerful people in this world. Few of them are responsible.
0
+
Reply Add Quote and ReplyMulti Quote
Post ID: 3097032 Posted at: 27-Feb-2012 17:45:27
CRAZY CHEATS
Das Milkinator
Member
Joined: 29 Mar 2007
Posts: 3,749
Post Likes: 0
+
I'm not too detailed on the ins and outs of communism, but I know the general picture, and it seems like a fairly decent idea. Would I prefer it over capitalism? Probably not, but if a true, uncorrupted communist government were to take over and stick to the principals, I wouldn't be too unhappy.
Now known as
0
+
Reply Add Quote and ReplyMulti Quote
Post ID: 3097051 Posted at: 27-Feb-2012 18:12:44
steelersrock01
Admin
Joined: 29 Nov 2006
Posts: 14,635
Post Likes: 68
+
CRAZY CHEATS said: a true, uncorrupted communist government

And this, right here, is the problem I think most communist states have faced. Currently, are there any true Communist states? Or are they just socialist countries trying to be communist? Anyway, let's look at the states that we view as Communist:
North Korea
China
Vietnam
Cuba


Now, none of these countries seem to exactly be doing great in the social welfare area of government. Is that a fault of Communism itself, or the people that run the Communist government? If done correctly, with competent people in a government free of corruption, I believe Communism could work well. But we may also be past that point in history.


0
+
Reply Add Quote and ReplyMulti Quote
Post ID: 3097538 Posted at: 29-Feb-2012 08:57:00
CRAZY CHEATS
Das Milkinator
Member
Joined: 29 Mar 2007
Posts: 3,749
Post Likes: 0
+
It's gotta be down to the people.
I remember my mom telling me about a small village in england, where the people have dedicated a plot of land to growing vegetables. Everyone helps with it, and in return everyone takes what they need from it. It's a very small example of communism working, but an example nonetheless.
Of course, theres a big difference between veggies and a country.
Now known as
0
+
Reply Add Quote and ReplyMulti Quote
Displaying Page 1 of 1. | Go To Page:

Subscribe to this topic Low Bandwidth Favourite Forums
Search this topic:

Currently viewing this thread:
REPLY IN THIS THREAD
Smilies, click to use

By posting on the SuperCheats forums, you agree to adhere to our forum rules.
You must be logged in to reply:
Username:  P/ W:  
Users under 13 are not eligible to post on the SuperCheats forums.
Forgotten your username and password? Click here to get it resent to you.
Click here to register for free.