Yeah, I joined when I was 11. Didn't tell a single soul though. I thought somehow my mom would find out, and I'd have my
ass handed to me. :p
The large amounts of forums we had before (I'm assuming you mean the old GC forums - Music, G&A, SCT, Books, etc.) would be improbably now, maybe even worse for the forums than the merged GC forum. The more forums there are like that, the more dead and empty the site looks. Now, because it's all in one, the forum won't look over half-empty.
I honestly don't see the heaps of active members in either forum. There are a few regular posters and the random people that drop in for a week at most. But heaps of active members? Nah... I guess I haven't done too much looking around the rest of the forums though, either...
--
But yes. The layout definitely needs a change. And a reorganisation. The old, old, OLD forums need to get archived. Submissions need to be gone through and sorted - there are still some complete crap subs on the site, along with some duplicates.
The only bad thing about being called "Supercheats" is that it looks like the site is dedicated only to cheating. And like you said, Mike, cheating isn't much of a 'thing' anymore. The only time people go back and play the games that have those kinds of cheats in them are ones doing it for nostalgia, and they aren't gonna wanna cheat anyway.
Sure, we have hints for individual games. But they're organised like crap, and are honestly just bullshit submissions anyway. In my opinion. The focus on Guides and Wikis is great - I think they're potentially the two most important things on the main site. But the execution was lame. I was active on the site when they added Guides, and I honestly didn't even know they were added, just due to lack of real talk about it. And when I just came back with this account, I didn't even notice that there were Wikis right away.
And there's a bonus. Looking at both the Guides and the Wikis, the first thing I think is "Where am I?" The organisation on both of them is horrendous, especially the Wikis. That needs to be fixed - Like I said, I feel like they're both going to be insanely important in getting this site (forums in particular) back up to activity.
Even just looking at the navigation bar... I can't believe the general layout of it hasn't changed at all for a decade. The appearance of it has changed, but it's always been the same. I think the biggest changes it has had are just... adding the 'Wiki' and 'Guide' likes, and grouping the consoles together by brand. Other than that, it's been the same since at least 2004 - Top row is consoles, bottom row is submissions.
I honestly think guest posting needs to be completely removed. It has always almost made the site look completely unprofessional and... almost 'dirty.' Anytime I see a guest post, it just makes me feel embarrassed. Some of the members' (few years ago, meaning) grammar was bad enough, but looked professional compared to some of the crap guests post...