Your Account
    Log into your account here:
       Forgot Password

    Not registered? Sign Up for free
    Registration allows you to keep track of all your content and comments, save bookmarks, and post in all our forums.
Pokemon Pearl

Rotom Debate - Legendary or Not?

Subscribe to topic Low Bandwidth Favourite Forums

Down to Quick Reply
Displaying Page 1 of 8

First | 2 | 3 | 4 | 6 | 7 | Last     Next
EspeonDude_ Posted at: 13:23 May19 2007 Post ID: 1604778
EspeonDude_
AvatarMember
Posts: 16,390
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
What do you think? Is Rotom a Legendary? Give your valid reasons why.

Votes:

Yes it is. - 1
No it's not. - 3
What's Rotom? -
Abstain. - 2

I'm abstain. I think it could be, but also couldn't be. It, like the other legendaries are available AFTER the National Dex, it's only one of a kind I think, the screen shakes and has the legendary battle music. Too many people think it isn't, which is why I'm abstain.

What do you think?

« Last edited by EspeonDude_ on May 19th 2007 »


[hmespeon -at- hotmail -dot- com] <~ MSN.
Big Shady Posted at: 13:39 May19 2007 Post ID: 1604811
Big Shady
AvatarBanned
Posts: 1,970
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
Abstian, to much confusion. It's a one and only per game Pokemon, and has a "scene", it's stats I'm not sure of.
Hmph.

Nobody's gonna stand in my way.
Stupid Nino Posted at: 15:10 May19 2007 Post ID: 1604970
Stupid Nino
AvatarMember
Posts: 1,936
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
Rotom has pretty good Sp. Attack.All the other stats ... aren't too good though.

And I don't think it's a Legendary. Just a rare guy.
irollgen4s Posted at: 17:09 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605228
irollgen4s
AvatarMember
Posts: 2,600
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
not a legendary IMO.


credit= EspeonDude_(not husky boy <_<)

Pokemon diamond friend code is 2835 6576 4587. my name is Ryan with only the R capi
PieLord of Doom Posted at: 17:51 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605325
PieLord of Doom
AvatarMember
Posts: 293
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
I'd have to agree with stupid Nino. Rotom is rare, because there is only one in each game, but it isn't a legendary. It's like the Starters. You can only have one of them, not all of them (unless you trade).


[center]Join the [b][/b]OUTCASTS OF EXISTENCE![/center]
Options of Death
1. Kick Balls Jutsu (If woman, please refer to option 2-4)
2. Kunai-in-throat Jutsu
3. Kunai Machine Gun Jutsu
4. Atom Bomb Jutsu
Husky Boy Posted at: 19:13 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605504
Husky Boy
AvatarMember
Posts: 2,899
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
I'm not sure, but since it has the legendary screen and music, I think so.(Hey, we can't base legendaries on their looks and stats). But come to think of it, read it's pokedex info.

Signature and Avatar Credit goes to me!
Status: Online.
JOIN TEAM RACKISTAS IF YOU LOVE MUSIC
dragonmaster745 Posted at: 19:53 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605618
dragonmaster745
AvatarMember
Posts: 3,534
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
Its not legendary I brought it into the battle tower.

Name: David
brawl fc: 1418-6442-8427
No 1 Luigi on SC
EspeonDude_ Posted at: 19:57 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605638
EspeonDude_
AvatarMember
Posts: 16,390
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
Latios and Latias are allowed in there too.


[hmespeon -at- hotmail -dot- com] <~ MSN.
dragonmaster745 Posted at: 20:06 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605701
dragonmaster745
AvatarMember
Posts: 3,534
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
well they aern't really legendary. They aern't in any legends in the anime series.

Name: David
brawl fc: 1418-6442-8427
No 1 Luigi on SC
ashaman_kae_17 Posted at: 20:45 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605823
ashaman_kae_17
AvatarMember
Posts: 2,234
Post Likes: 3
+
0
+
they have a whole movie based after them...and frankly...tell me one movie that was based after a non-legendary pokemon, and Ill drop my support of Rotom being a legendary...based on being able to bring it, latias and latios in(yes I agree with that)
[b][center]
[color=darkred]drop me a line on my Gaia account: X x XCaracarnX x X
dragonmaster745 Posted at: 20:54 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605854
dragonmaster745
AvatarMember
Posts: 3,534
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
Well.... Deoxys isn't for say legendary.

Name: David
brawl fc: 1418-6442-8427
No 1 Luigi on SC
ashaman_kae_17 Posted at: 21:01 May19 2007 Post ID: 1605872
ashaman_kae_17
AvatarMember
Posts: 2,234
Post Likes: 3
+
0
+
He(Deoxys) is an event pokemon, which I would consider legendary...and to boot go here: Click Me

EDIT*(Oh sorry...I figured that most people here would know the reliability of serebii...but my point was that he is listed as a Legendary on the Pokemon Sapphire/Ruby selection...the article was written prior to the eon ticket and to the release of emerald...so thus the information was at that time true...)I wasnt using Serebii as the basis for my argument...only support, and sources can be reliable...or unreliable on certain points...you have to for yourself pick fact from fake)

« Last edited by ashaman_kae_17 on May 19th 2007 »
[b][center]
[color=darkred]drop me a line on my Gaia account: X x XCaracarnX x X
PieLord of Doom Posted at: 22:55 May19 2007 Post ID: 1606134
PieLord of Doom
AvatarMember
Posts: 293
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
Ashaman_Kae_17, i dont mean to be rude, but that link leads to a VERY UNRELIABLE SITE. I mean, cmon, just read it. Groudon is only in Ruby? Bat feces. Latias is only found in Saphire? Cow manure. Serebii is incredibly unreliabe. Although, It is right about a VERY few things. Like Deoxys is a Legendary.


[center]Join the [b][/b]OUTCASTS OF EXISTENCE![/center]
Options of Death
1. Kick Balls Jutsu (If woman, please refer to option 2-4)
2. Kunai-in-throat Jutsu
3. Kunai Machine Gun Jutsu
4. Atom Bomb Jutsu
Master Volthawk Posted at: 22:58 May19 2007 Post ID: 1606139
Master Volthawk
AvatarMember
Posts: 19,631
Post Likes: 1
+
0
+
serebii just fails to update their information for the older games. Doesn't make it as unreliable as you claim.

Back on topic, I am abstain in this matter.
PieLord of Doom Posted at: 23:02 May19 2007 Post ID: 1606143
PieLord of Doom
AvatarMember
Posts: 293
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
On 19-May-2007 Master Volthawk said:serebii just fails to update their information for the older games. Doesn't make it as unreliable as you claim.

Back on topic, I am abstain in this matter.
What do you believe, Volthawk? Should Rotom be considered as a Legend or something else?

P.S. If they don't update the site for older games, then it is unreliable. It misleads other people. But, you're right, back on topic.


[center]Join the [b][/b]OUTCASTS OF EXISTENCE![/center]
Options of Death
1. Kick Balls Jutsu (If woman, please refer to option 2-4)
2. Kunai-in-throat Jutsu
3. Kunai Machine Gun Jutsu
4. Atom Bomb Jutsu
mr.619 Posted at: 23:03 May19 2007 Post ID: 1606146
mr.619
Wisco
AvatarMember
Posts: 5,823
Post Likes: 5
+
0
+
Hes a legendary.. I checked the list.
Master Volthawk Posted at: 23:04 May19 2007 Post ID: 1606149
Master Volthawk
AvatarMember
Posts: 19,631
Post Likes: 1
+
0
+
Look at the top of this thread. You should see that you can vote being abstain on this matter. If you can't see it, put your glasses on �_�.
PieLord of Doom Posted at: 23:07 May19 2007 Post ID: 1606152
PieLord of Doom
AvatarMember
Posts: 293
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
*ACTIVATES HIPPIE TALKING SYSTEM* Are you going to have a list decide everything for you? Where did you get this *List*, man? Are you gonna let other people's opinions on what it and what's not decide your opinion?
I still believe Rotom isn't a legendary, just rare.

« Last edited by PieLord of Doom on May 19th 2007 »


[center]Join the [b][/b]OUTCASTS OF EXISTENCE![/center]
Options of Death
1. Kick Balls Jutsu (If woman, please refer to option 2-4)
2. Kunai-in-throat Jutsu
3. Kunai Machine Gun Jutsu
4. Atom Bomb Jutsu
ashaman_kae_17 Posted at: 23:16 May19 2007 Post ID: 1606170
ashaman_kae_17
AvatarMember
Posts: 2,234
Post Likes: 3
+
0
+
Ya know I just thought about it...and the show makes Lucario out to be a Legendary...but in the game...not as much so...especially seeing as you can breed him to get more...so what Im saying is...that Im retracting my claim for him(Rotom) being Legendary to say he's not(dangit...I hate when I bring evidence up to discredit myself -_-)

« Last edited by ashaman_kae_17 on May 19th 2007 »
[b][center]
[color=darkred]drop me a line on my Gaia account: X x XCaracarnX x X
Pooly Posted at: 08:45 May20 2007 Post ID: 1606696
Pooly
The Sheep Lover
AvatarMember
Posts: 12,342
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
I say he ain't he's just a pokemon which is a one of a kind like the starters and isn't legendary even though he has the scene and music, but thats just my opinion.

Credit to .Impact for the sig & avy
Displaying Page 1 of 8

First | 2 | 3 | 4 | 6 | 7 | Last     Next
Subscribe to topic Low Bandwidth Favourite Forums

Members viewing this thread:
This topic has been closed by 447680

Post Top
Click to close