Your Account
    Log into your account here:
       Forgot Password

    Not registered? Sign Up for free
    Registration allows you to keep track of all your content and comments, save bookmarks, and post in all our forums.
Red Dead Redemption

Discuss the story (Mostly the end) SPOILERS! SO MANY SPOILERS! You've been warned

Subscribe to topic Low Bandwidth Favourite Forums

Down to Quick Reply
Displaying Page 1 of 1

CRAZY CHEATS Posted at: 08:52 Jun30 2010 Post ID: 2861971
CRAZY CHEATS
Das Milkinator
AvatarMember
Posts: 3,748
Post Likes: 1
+
0
+
I found the end so sad and disapointing. John untimely demise was simply heartbreaking, and the full on end wasn't nearly as satisfying as I had hoped it would be.
Now known as
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
sphynxx Posted at: 02:02 Jul02 2010 Post ID: 2862744
sphynxx
.:I Am What You Fear Most:.
AvatarMember
Posts: 11,722
Post Likes: 102
+
0
+
I have to agree with you on that point.

When the final mission (Johns) took place, I was thinking, alright, the barn has a window, I have full dead eye, plus 5 each of snake oil, moonshine, tobacco, with a butt-load of ammo. I can take these fools.

Then... well, you know what happened Not Talking


<3 to Craizen for the Avatar & TheLlama for the Signature.


"Forever in this heart of mine, an everlasting bond. From now until the end of time, are memories so fond."


Juli said:I am officially a Sphynx fangirl. C:
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
CRAZY CHEATS Posted at: 05:01 Jul02 2010 Post ID: 2862782
CRAZY CHEATS
Das Milkinator
AvatarMember
Posts: 3,748
Post Likes: 1
+
0
+
Yeah, I thought that like, I dunno, somebody would turn and save you at the last minute or something.
Now known as
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
sphynxx Posted at: 21:56 Jul02 2010 Post ID: 2863127
sphynxx
.:I Am What You Fear Most:.
AvatarMember
Posts: 11,722
Post Likes: 102
+
0
+
I just figured it was going to be a hell of a fire fight then we had to take off & evade the lawmen & then re-group with the family or something.

If anyone else aside from Tony & myself come in here & you haven't finished the game, don't read this next part;

Spoiler:
click to reveal


<3 to Craizen for the Avatar & TheLlama for the Signature.


"Forever in this heart of mine, an everlasting bond. From now until the end of time, are memories so fond."


Juli said:I am officially a Sphynx fangirl. C:
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
CRAZY CHEATS Posted at: 06:57 Jul03 2010 Post ID: 2863238
CRAZY CHEATS
Das Milkinator
AvatarMember
Posts: 3,748
Post Likes: 1
+
0
+
Oh yeah, Jack's such a dweeb.
With his bad goatee.....
Now known as
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
bowow Posted at: 16:25 Jul05 2010 Post ID: 2864068
bowow
The Lizard King
AvatarMember
Posts: 2,198
Post Likes: 4
+
0
+
It would of made an even better ending for like Jack and Uncle to just kick the crap out of the lawmen.

And they made a big mistake by having a strangers task to be killing Edgar Ross, they could of made a whole new game.

Cred to TheLlama for the Siggy! And PBO for the Avy!

Blurred Voice said:Female, you just stick a blunt object in your fun hole and nothing comes of it. Man, you grab your pork stick and send little ghost looking things from a Mario game everywhere.
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
CRAZY CHEATS Posted at: 17:02 Jul05 2010 Post ID: 2864101
CRAZY CHEATS
Das Milkinator
AvatarMember
Posts: 3,748
Post Likes: 1
+
0
+
Couldn't really.
The west is dead.
Now known as
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
sphynxx Posted at: 02:09 Jul06 2010 Post ID: 2864345
sphynxx
.:I Am What You Fear Most:.
AvatarMember
Posts: 11,722
Post Likes: 102
+
0
+
Agreed. The west is dead yo.

There could be scope for a new game with Jack heading off to L.A or San Fran (after-all, both are mentioned in the story-line) to track down the Agency & try get more revenge or something. But I doubt it lol.


<3 to Craizen for the Avatar & TheLlama for the Signature.


"Forever in this heart of mine, an everlasting bond. From now until the end of time, are memories so fond."


Juli said:I am officially a Sphynx fangirl. C:
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
Xeta Posted at: 15:24 Aug08 2011 Post ID: 3050024
Xeta
Beneta
AvatarMember
Posts: 6,133
Post Likes: 79
+
0
+
Oh my god the ending was so perfect are you guys kidding me? Probably one of the greatest game endings I've ever seen, John's death symbolizes the death of the wild west.

I don't think the would continue with the story. At least I hope not.
ozzo said:xeta actually makes a lot of sense most of the time

if everyone agreed with him more often we wouldnt have this problem
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
geezerguy Posted at: 18:21 Aug08 2011 Post ID: 3050157
geezerguy
Jailbait / Lukie
AvatarMember
Posts: 14,016
Post Likes: 43
+
0
+
While the end really annoyed me and was sad, I agree with Ben. Everything would have been just too perfect if the guys just let him live happily ever after, which would have been a worse ending.

The whole story was very good, though. As much as I loved the game and would play the sequel if one was made, I don't think they should make one. At least not of a continuation of this story, because Jack is terrible.
Winner of Member Brawl 2011 <3
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
Xeta Posted at: 12:33 Aug23 2011 Post ID: 3056212
Xeta
Beneta
AvatarMember
Posts: 6,133
Post Likes: 79
+
0
+
And the fact that it wouldn't be much of a story since it's 1914.
ozzo said:xeta actually makes a lot of sense most of the time

if everyone agreed with him more often we wouldnt have this problem
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
Forum Guest Posted at: 11:04 Aug27 2012 Post ID: 3143941
Forum Guest
Forum Guest
Jack in world war one
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti QuoteEdit
Robo Redneck Posted at: 12:25 Mar04 2013 Post ID: 3221518
Robo Redneck
AvatarMember
Posts: 4
Post Likes: 0
+
0
+
that's call of duty
Reply Quote & ReplyMulti Quote
Displaying Page 1 of 1

Subscribe to topic Low Bandwidth Favourite Forums

Members viewing this thread:
REPLY IN THIS THREAD
Smilies, click to use

You must be logged in to reply:
Username: 
Password:   
Forgot password? Click here to get it resent to you.
Sign Up Register for free.

Users under 13 are not eligible to post on the SuperCheats forums.

Post Top
Click to close