Character Replacements

On 22-Jan-2009 Fusion_Blastoise said:

There are diffrent tier lists for Melee as there was several diffreneces in the two games. ie. fox was nerfed considerably.

Captain Falcon was 'nerfed' even worse, as were Ganondorf, Sheik and Samus.

i got a new one
replace toon link for someone from a sonic game
toon link is really like a clone to link.He got the same moves and final smash

On 11-Jan-2009 Volke said:

I'm fine with the characters that were kicked out of Melee, with the exception of Dr. Mario, who was the only good one.

I didn't see the point of adding Lucas into the game without ditching Ness, because the two are exactly the same.

I was also disappointed with Ike. Being an amazing unit in the Fire Emblem games, it's quite unrealistic that he was screwed over in Brawl due to his horrible lag. At least Marth's back in and is still awesome.

Jigglypuff to be replaced by Roy? Hahaha...no.

Ness and Lucas are actually the most different of all the clones in this game if you think about it different standard b Pk fire is different Ness's stays Lucas's disappears Ness uses Yoyo's and bats for Smash atacks Lucas uses PK power and a stick Lucas has a tether Lucas's Pk thunder can go through a character and Ness' dissapears Also when you hit yourself with it then someone else ness sends the opponent flying and Lucas does more damage Ness' down-special covers him completelly and Lucas' only covers the front also I think Lucas's damages when released near an opponent and ness' pushes away but it might be vice-versa.

replace Ganondorf with Tails. That'd be sweet..:P

that's a good idea

Let's see..replace Wario with Roy! XP

« Last edited by on Feb 11th 2009 »

Wario is a great character. Roy was mediocre. Need I say more?

Ganondorf for Tails sounds a bit crap, too.

What, you have something better than mine?

« Last edited by on Feb 12th 2009 »

Yes. Bring back Dr. Mario. That's all they need to do. They don't need another Sonic character, and Sonic was bad anyway. Roy was mediocre and far inferior to Marth. No need for him. At least Ike is quite different.

Dr. mario should be back along with mewtwo
they both were good characters but I would've liked to see somone out of the box you know (besides mr. game and watch) hes too bland but meta knight should stay he is the BOMB DIGGITY!
anyway i liked that they gotrid of pichu it was to odd of a character and pretty much the same as pikachu only hurts itself

You're right about Pichu.

On 12-Feb-2009 Volke said:

Yes. Bring back Dr. Mario. That's all they need to do. They don't need another Sonic character, and Sonic was bad anyway. Roy was mediocre and far inferior to Marth. No need for him. At least Ike is quite different.

So you think roy is Mediocre (he was my favorite character) and you want to put another clone in the game I say Marth should be replaceed by Roy.

On 12-Feb-2009 Volke said:

Yes. Bring back Dr. Mario. That's all they need to do. They don't need another Sonic character, and Sonic was bad anyway. Roy was mediocre and far inferior to Marth. No need for him. At least Ike is quite different.

i don't understand....sonic character are really good and once you master sonics moves you can do all the great tricks and imagine if they put knuckles, it would be great because he has a lot of power
i still like the dr.mario idea

jose22_98 - Hey, if Roy ws your favourite charar, it doesn't mean he was good. It just means that if you think you're good at the game, you're kidding yourself. Replace Marth with Roy? Very bad idea. Marth was so much better.

mini_mario - The tier lists will disagree with Sonic being much good, but I guess Knuckles would be preferable to Tails.

On 11-Feb-2009 Krystal_Kirby_Shards said:

Let's see..replace Wario with Roy! XP

i would never ditch Ganondorf

Well needless to say but I think Olimar should leave. Most people I know said he sucks. But that isn't my opinion. I would like to see Dr.Mario to make a return,but he wasn't my ace. I would like to see Darkrai be part of the SSB team.

On 14-Feb-2009 Volke said:

jose22_98 - Hey, if Roy ws your favourite charar, it doesn't mean he was good. It just means that if you think you're good at the game, you're kidding yourself. Replace Marth with Roy? Very bad idea. Marth was so much better.

mini_mario - The tier lists will disagree with Sonic being much good, but I guess Knuckles would be preferable to Tails.

And if you pick your charcater because of a teir list your bound to fail. I use and have mastered Sonic as everyone knows. I'm just one example of how Teirs mean nothing.

On 16-Feb-2009 bomba said:

And if you pick your charcater because of a teir list your bound to fail. I use and have mastered Sonic as everyone knows. I'm just one example of how Teirs mean nothing.

Same thing here. I have mastered with Sonic so there is no point of him leaving.

On 16-Feb-2009 ChrisMaclean said:

Well needless to say but I think Olimar should leave. Most people I know said he sucks. But that isn't my opinion. I would like to see Dr.Mario to make a return,but he wasn't my ace. I would like to see Darkrai be part of the SSB team.

darkrai would be most likely a boss enemy in the ssb series

True,but Mewtwo looks likes a boss. They should've put him as a boss.