Best Game of the series so far?

Do you think Phantom Hourglass was the best Zelda game released so far? What woud you rate it?

I'd give it a 8/10. Twilight Princess is the best so far in my opinion.

no
it wasn't the best but it was second best first was tp

On 28-Nov-2007 StarDust shall live said:

no
it wasn't the best but it was second best first was tp

yeah but what rating would you give it

i would give it a 7/10 because the way that when you try to draw the triforce which is really hard to draw in the temple of the sea king

it was not hard

I say 5/10 not my fave, too short I like long games like the three disc final fantasy game that I can't beat in a couple days. Ocarina was best and Tp was second this is fifth.

really???

to short and not enough items.6/10

T_p was the best.

On 29-Nov-2007 PhilXZ said:

really???

you need three words per post

Oricania of time was the best.

i think this was the best because it was the longest if you count wind waker. it WAS a continuation you know. i would rate it 9/10

Well I haven't been on in a while, but Legend of Zelda is my favorite series, so I had to type. I'll rate the games from fave to least fave:
1. Original Zelda- it was very very hard and extremely long,not to mention it was the basis for them all
2. TP, wind waker, adn Hourglass i'd give all about a 9/11- all had great storylines, lots of weapons, and lots of creativity
3.Ocarina of Time- you have to admit, for the 64, this was an instant classic
4. Majora's Mask- 4/11- three day thing at beginning way to challenging for amateur zelda fan
5. Link's Awakening-2/10- not well put together.

On 03-Dec-2007 pokemaster1197 said:

i think this was the best because it was the longest if you count wind waker. it WAS a continuation you know. i would rate it 9/10

Well you also have ocarina continued by majoras mask.

I'd say its good, but not great, to short, 8/10 at best.
Majora's Mask was the best until Twilight Princess, it was awesome, the 3 days time limit was also quite good, and it was the first Zelda game I completed.

Well, Phatom Hourglass is okay, but I wouldn't give it a great score. It's better than Twilight Princess and Wind Waker for sure.

I say it's better than WW and maybe TP, but MM is probably the best game in the series.

On 04-Dec-2007 Pooly said:

I say it's better than WW and maybe TP, but MM is probably the best game in the series.

Yeah I agree with you pooly,, MM was proably the best zelda game in series

Majoras was to short for me even with the masks.

You peeps have to admit, the first Zelda was by far the longest and hardest, even if others were more favorable.

The first... I can speed run in 33 minutes