Supercheats Unofficial Tier List (Third Draft)

This is the Third Draft of the unofficial Supercheats tier list.

The following is based purely off of the opinions of users here, and is therefore not

accurate. This is the first of drafts that will be created and tested in order to make the

most accurate "unofficial tier list."


Comments and criticism are completely welcome, and will be taken into consideration. Feel

free to speak your mind (no flamming please). If there are any suggestions as to movement

of a character, they will be posted right under here for approval

of remaining members here.


NOTE: Character movements to different tiers is now allowed!!!



Current character movements requests:
- None


The List (Draft)

Top
Meta Knight
Marth

Upper
Wolf
Pikmin and Olimar
Pit
Toon Link
Lucario
Solid Snake
Falco Lombardi
Luigi
Wario
King Dedede
Princess Peach
Mr. Game and Watch

High Middle
Lucas
Fox McCloud
Pokemon Trainer
Link
Zero Suit Samus
Mario
Ike
Pikachu
Samus Aran
Ice Climbers
Sheik
Kirby
Diddy Kong
Jigglypuff

Low Middle
Ness
Yoshi
Zelda
Captain Falcon
R.O.B

Lower
Bowser
Donkey Kong
Sonic the Hedgehog
Ganondorf


Remember this information is still under construction, and will be updating constantly.

Post away your opinions!

« Last edited by johnkrill on Jul 3rd 2008 »

looks pretty good to me.

i seriously say Captain Olimar sucks.

Pikmin just plainly suck in general and i dont know Why it was even added in to Brawl. i think even Magikarp would have been more powerful then Olimar. i say drop him to low middle class

low middle class? This isn't an airplane flight. Do you have any reasons why olimar sucks? No, he's actually really good, possibly one of the best characters in the game.

i fight the thing when he's Lv 9 computer. he cant even inflict damage on me, when i basically just sit still.

edit: For the record, i use Wolf here

« Last edited by poke.addicted on Jun 4th 2008 »

yeah and thats why, wolf is probably the cheapest character in the entire game. You can spam his side smash across the entire stage, or just spam blaster. He' stronger then fox and falco, harder to knock off, and almost as fast. And his recovery is decent also. He is the most ridiculously overpowered character in the game.

and yet, i see the following..

Top
Meta Knight
Marth

Upper
Wolf

and hes the most overpowered? D: Olimar just looks retarded, and cant seriously hit me, even when im Ganondorf / Bowser. a Lower Class.

once again, we're not on a plane, its BOTTOM TIER. I don't care who you can hit with. You really aren't doing too good a job at proving any points at why Olimar is bad. This isn't a authentic tier either, so it's not like it's the legit thing.

Sorry to burst your ego there, but playing a Level 9 is like playing a dead corpse that has no fingers. I'm fairly sure it's not the best thing you'll face, so you not taking damage isn't something special.

Thanks KoH. Point proven. Now go play with olimar you idiot.

did you just call me an idiot? seriously, thats how it looks, and very bad idea.

Please control yourselves. This topic needs constuctive thoughts, not criticism.

But Poke, you really do need to base the strength of a cahracter on more than jus its strength as a level 9 computer.

I thought Olimar was bottom tier until I actually started playing him, and it turns out that he is actually quite good, which is why he has been rated so highly.

Olimar is good, he can do long range attacks and short range attacks with and without pikmin. (I think it's funny to hear the death crys of pikmin). I think Olimar is a pretty balanced character if you ask me.

I would like to see Zelda at least in the High Middle, one of her side attacks, where she makes the explosive ball, is pretty effective for long and short ranges. And she can use that to get the smash ball faster. (trust me, i was battling someone using her, and everytime there was a smash ball, he would use that explosion ball to get it, before we even had a chance to get it! It took about three explosion's for zelda to have final smash!)

Seems good to me. I still have a couple objections as to which tier some of the characters belong in, but since that has been decided and probably wont change, I am content

I really only have three objections (and they are pretty minor anyway)

A Falco should be moved further down

B Pokemon Trainer should be moved further down

C Diddy Kong should be moved up

« Last edited by Dozin26 on Jun 4th 2008 »

Am I the only one who uses sonic as my main? Really? Dang, to bad he's in the lowest.

woah everyone stop!! XD

first thing i saw i say Toon Link should go above lucario

I think sonic should at leats be in low middle, I mean he's an awesome character and can rack up damage easily (Well when I play him).

Lol I main Olimar and he doesn't suck hes just broken :D

Get Gaanon OUT OF THE LOWER.

Thank you.

In before SNAKE IS TOP TIER YOU GUYS SUCK.

Get Capn out of that low-middle tier. He's awesome.