1th:When you first met Roger in the Duggues forrest, did you made him temporary join you? if so then it's good.
2nd: when you met Roger again in Surferio,, Did you said No or Yes to let him join you again? Here you have to say No. (I think, that's what it says in the guide though..)
3rd: For Roger: The third time you met Roger leaves it open to get him. after coming back to Elicoor -> Surferio and then recruit him.
- if it still doesen't work then it have to do something about what you did from the first and second time you met Roger.
| What goes up , Must come down |