I think the format of the last SuperCheats Awards was nice... I think the following should be the polls, in my opinion ;P
Best Member (with member status)
Best Mod
Best Super Mod
Best Admin
Best newcoming Member
Best Member with Banned Status (at the current time)
Best Video Game Forum Mod
Best General Board Mod
Funniest Member
Most sarcastic Member
Funniest Screenname
Most random Member
Most serious Member
Best Avy
Best Sig
Best Graphics artist
Best Fan Fiction writer
Best Role Player
Most dedicated Member
Most active Member
Best Team or Clan
Most likely to get a promotion from their current rank
Member with most contribution to the site
Most missed Member
Favourite male
Favourite female
Best overall Member
It's long but it's a mix of both Awards threads. Or was there a reason why you chose not to include some of these?
Avatar: In memory of ieatwyverns <3
Thank you, Vasco <3