Glad you're taking action on the rules and moderators, Rich.
I very much like the sound of making the Rules into Guidelines, it sounds much more friendlier, and as soon as a new member heres the word "Rules" I think they lose interest a little bit, because in my eyes they come here to get away from the rules of school/work, etc. So, yeah, agreed about the Guidelines part. I agree with whoever said about the three word rule, too. I know you had good intentions with this rule, but I really don't think it is needed, simply because "Yeah." is no different to "Yeah, it is.". These hidden rules also need to be added, too, such as double posting, etc. Caps lock rule; After thinking a little I think it is neccessary, it really does look ugly, but should be changed from flaming to something else.
I noticed you were cleaning out moderators before this thread and I'm glad you and the Super Mods will be hand picking them.
I also think you should do tournaments for other games, I saw SoH mentioned Guitar Hero earlier. I believe a GH tournament would be a great idea - I know the forums for the game really aren't too active, but there's no doubt A LOT of people play it here.
I'll be trying to think of some other ideas after this post..
Winner of Member Brawl 2011 <3