My NFL Draft Grades
Buffalo Bills: B Tampa Bay showed how to defeat the Chiefs in the Super Bowl: Pressure, Pressure, and More Pressure. So what do the Bills do? Use not just their 1st but also their 2nd on an Edge Rusher. Rousseau is a risk after only having one big year in College, while Basham is a more safe pick but has the lowest ceiling of all the Top DEs. Middle Round Picks were decent, love WR Stevenson and S Hamlin for additional depth.
Miami Dolphins: B Difficult to grade the Dolphins. Waddle and Phillips have the chance to be huge boom picks, but both have had previous injuries. Their Day 2 Picks had the common theme of being proven consistent talents in College. Unfortunately, didn't have a pick for 150 Selection after #81, but they did fill basically all of their keys needs outside of RB and LB. Watch out for the Phins to be a sleeper Rodgers trade destination as they have three 1sts in the next two draft and could trade Tua for more of them.
New England Patriots: C I don't really like the Patriots Class. Mac Jones is a fit, but he's not very talented. They got steals on Day 2 with Barmore and Perkins. Day 3 Picks were all for depth. If Mac Jones pans out, could easily be a higher grade.
New York Jets: B+ I love how the Jets gave barely any help to Darnold for three years but used their succeeding three selections to build around Wilson after taking him at #2. Wilson fills their greatest need, but could be a boom or bust player. I love their picks of Vera-Tucker, Moore, and Carter. I don't see them being all that great next year, but it's a step in the right direction.
Baltimore Ravens: B+ The Ravens usually score high year after year, and this draft is no different. Bateman will fits perfectly alongside Hollywood Brown and the aging Watkins, while Oweh has all the potential in the world. Cleveland could fill the hole left by Yanda a few years ago. Wallace and Wade could be Middle Round Steals.
Cincinnati Bengals: B+ I didn't like them going Chase over Sewell, but they did pick up Carman in the second. I'm not sure if Carman will pan out as a LT, but he was a former 5-Star Recruit coming out of high school. Ossai in the 3rd and Shelvin in the 4th were great value.
Cleveland Browns: B I had Newsome going as high as #20, so the Browns didn't reach for him. It didn't fill their greatest of needs, but it was nice selection considering they will need all the help in their Secondary if they ever want to dethrone the Chiefs. Owusu-Koramoah is the 2nd was a steal. All depth players after that.
Pittsburgh Steelers: B The Steelers were clearly going for high upside guys. Harris, Friermuth, Green, Moore, and Johnson could easily all be starters next year and for years to come. Later Round Picks were decent.
Houston Texans: D I get the Mills Pick since Watson is likely done for the Texans, but they honestly could've gotten a better role player and just tank next year. That said, I love Mills' potential. Jordan was also a good pick. Didn't like their other selections, though.
Indianapolis Colts: C The Colts are usually better than this. Paye and Odeyinbo both have high ceilings, but they each come at a risk. Paye was a one year wonder, and Odeyinbo has serious injury concerns. If they pan out, they can each be superstars. The rest of their selections were just okay.
Jacksonville Jaguars: A They were going to get an A regardless for walking away with Lawrence, but I like all of their picks through the first four rounds. Etienne is highly productive, Campbell is a former 5-Star Recruit, Little is a former 5-Star Recruit, Cisco would've gone late 1st if not for injuries, and Tufele and Smith should contribute Day 1.
Tennessee Titans: B- Farley is either going to be a boom or bust guy depending on his durability. Radunz, Rice, Weaver, and Molden are solid, but not off the charts. Overall, a decent draft with some questions.
Denver Broncos: C I thought they might add a CB at some point in the draft, but I would've never thought they would do so at #9. Clearly the Broncos are going to go all in on Rodgers. Not sure why they went with Williams since they have Gordon. Meinerz, Sterns, and Williams were nice picks.
Kansas City Chiefs: B+ Getting Bolton late in the 2nd was huge for the Chiefs; he should fit in nicely with them since they rotate their LBs constantly during games. Humphrey was a great pick as well; I think they will try to put him at Guard and move Long out to RT. Brown-Tuney-Blythe-Humphrey-Long would be a Top 5 O-Line. Trey Smith late could be the biggest steal of the draft if he can get his health in order; he is a Top 10 Draft Talent.
Las Vegas Raiders: C- The Leatherwood pick was a reach, but I think we all expected a stretch for the Raiders. Getting Moehrig in the 2dn was great value as some people were mocking him to the Raiders in the 1st Round. I didn't care for the rest of their selections.
Los Angeles Chargers: A Slater falling to #13 and Samuel to #47 were both dream scenarios for the Chargers. Palmer, Rumph, and McKitty should be nice backups. Nick Niemann could be a steal in the 6th after the Pro Day he had.
Dallas Cowboys: B An up and down Draft for the Cowboys. I loved the Parsons and Joseph Picks; I did't care for the Odighizuma and Gholston selections. I loved the Cox, Fehoko, and Mukuamu Picks; I didn't care for all of their other ones.
New York Giants: A After being robbed of Devonta Smith thanks to the Cowboys, the Giants were able to get WR4 while also adding a future 1st. That alone won the draft for them, but then they were able to also get Ojulari, Robinson, and Williams. Incredible.
Philadelphia Eagles: B Kudos for the Eagles actually having the brains to leapfrog the Giants for Smith; he fills a huge need. I don't understand the Dickerson pick, but I guess they are getting set for when Kelce retires. Gainwell in the 5th could be a steal.
Washington Redskins: C They had the opportunity to trade up for a guy like Fields, but chose not to. Even though the Davis and Cosmi picks were great, it's hard to give the Redskins a better grade when QB is still an issue. They will not be in the Rodgers Sweepstakes by all accounts. Ouch.
Chicago Bears: A Getting Fields in the 1st and Jenkins in the 2nd says it all. Easily a great draft for the Bears despite their later selections only being decent. Eight teams were said to have had a higher grade on Fields than even Lawrence!
Detroit Lions: B They clearly get an A for obtaining Sewell, but the Lions selections after that weren't stellar. Waiting until the 4th to get a WR might hurt them next year.
Green Bay Packers: F- They could've traded Rodgers for the #3 Pick, and then the Packers could've selected Pitts at #3 and ELijah Moore at #29. Once could argue Adams+Moore+Pitts could be one of the best receiving trio in the entire NFL, and they clearly would've helped Love transition early on next year. Bad move. To make matters worse, the Packers then reached for Stokes, Myers, and Rodgers. Another horrible Draft Weekend for the Packers.
Minnesota Vikings: B+ Another year of the Vikings having so many selections that they walk away with a good grade. Trading back and still getting Darrisaw was awesome. I don't like choosing Mond over Mills, but their Surratt, Davis, Jones, Smith-Marsette, Bynum, and Twyman Picks were all great.
Atlanta Falcons: B Great first three picks in Pitts, Grant, and Mayfield, but their rest were just decent. I think they really should've considered leapfrogging the Texans to nab Mills, but I don't mind them rolling with Matt Ryan for a few more years.
Carolina Panthers: A+ The best Draft Class in my eyes. Horn is a fierce competitor, and they desperately needing a CB. Marshall going late in the 2nd was incredible value. Christensen was a decent pick, but it does fill a need. Many think Tremble could eventually be the next Kittle so watch out for that, but at the bare minimum will be a great blocking H-Back for McCaffery. Hubbard is a nice backup option for McCaffery considering his recent injuries. Daviyon Nixon going #158 was a travesty. NFL Networks little Amazon Ratings thing has him 95/100. How in the world does a 1st Round talent fall to to 5th Round when there were absolutely no question makrs with the guy that I could find? Crazy. He will probably be another Iowa Hawkeye 5th Round steal (Kittle, King), awesome pick for the Panthers. Brown and Smith late were also great value.
New Orleans Saints: F Overreach on Turner. Overreach on Werner. Gave up far too much to jump for Adebo. Horrible overreach on Book. Enough said.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: C They literally drafted for depth the entire draft. Didn't love or hate any of their selections. A middle grade seems fair.
Arizona Cardinals: B Productive freak athletes with their first three picks in Collins, Moore, and Wilson. Each comes with a few questions marks or concerns, but they could each be boom picks if they pan out. Later picks were just okay.
Los Angeles Rams: C Much like the Bucs, I didn't love or hate any of the Rams picks. All of them were decent. Only negative I can really find is they didn't draft any O-Lineman, and I'm pretty sure they have a few holes along it to fill.
San Francisco 49ers: C I love the fact they went with Lance over Jones (even though I still believe Fields was QB2), but I don't really like anything the 49ers did afterward. Not a shocker, though, since Shanahan and Lynch are usually inconsistent drafters.
Seattle Seahawks: F You had Russell Wilson complaining enough about not having any blocking that there were floating rumors of him wanting to be trade. And yet, the Seahawks only select on O-Lineman in the draft, and not until the 6th Round. Horrible.
« Last edited by Warrior13 on May 2nd 2021 »